Steps to Take When the Other Driver Denies Fault in a Car Accident

May 15, 2024

Steps to Take When the Other Driver Denies Fault in a Car Accident

Navigating the aftermath of a car accident someone else caused can be daunting in any circumstances. It’s particularly challenging when the other driver disputes liability.

Knowing your rights and the essential steps to take in the aftermath of a crash with a driver who denies responsibility is critical now. Learn how to handle disputes in car accident claims, and you’ll be prepared to effectively defend your rights and pursue the compensation for which you may be eligible.

Key Takeaways:

  • When a motor vehicle collision occurs, both parties have responsibilities. Your primary duties are to ensure safety, report the incident, and accurately document it.
  • These responsibilities become even more significant when a negligent driver denies fault.
  • Documenting the incident thoroughly, communicating effectively, and knowing when to seek legal assistance can all play crucial roles in determining the outcome of your case.
  • An experienced car accident attorney can guide you through the complexities of fault disputes and help protect your rights.

What should you do immediately if the other driver denies fault after a car accident?

Do not argue with the other driver at the scene if they deny fault. Doing so could lead to a confrontation. Prioritize your safety first, exchange contact and insurance information with the other driver, and then document the accident scene thoroughly. This involves reporting the accident to the police, gathering witness information, and taking pictures. After seeking medical attention, consult with a qualified car accident attorney to discuss your legal alternatives and ensure your rights are protected.

Disputes over fault in car accidents can complicate the claims process. Thorough documentation and expert legal guidance are essential to protect your rights.”

Sidenote: Did you know? In West Virginia, fault can directly impact the compensation you may receive, as the state follows a modified comparative negligence rule.

Understanding the Basics of Fault in Car Accidents

Determining who is at fault is crucial for resolving insurance claims and legal responsibilities after a car wreck in West Virginia. Understanding fault in car accidents becomes even more important when the other driver denies fault.

What Does Fault Mean in Car Accidents?

Fault in car accidents refers to the responsibility one or more drivers bear for causing the accident. In legal terms, fault is often associated with negligence, which means failing to act with the care that a reasonably cautious person would under similar circumstances. For example, someone may be at fault in a car wreck if they caused a crash because they were speeding.

West Virginia’s Comparative Negligence Rule

Under West Virginia’s comparative negligence rule, someone can recoup losses if they are less than 50% responsible for the accident. However, the amount of compensation they may recover is reduced by their percentage of fault. For example, if someone is 20% to blame for a wreck, the most compensation they could receive is 20% less than they’d be eligible for if someone else was 100% responsible for the crash. This rule underscores the importance of establishing fault in accidents, especially when the other driver denies responsibility.

Immediate Steps to Take at the Accident Scene

Immediate Steps to Take at the Accident Scene

Your actions at the scene can significantly influence the result of any claims or legal proceedings. This is true regardless of whether another driver denies responsibility for a crash. The following are steps to take immediately after a collision:

Document the Scene

Capturing detailed information at the scene is crucial. Such evidence can be quite valuable when another driver denies fault:

  • Take Photos and Videos: Document all vehicles involved, their positions on the road, any visible damages, traffic signs, and road conditions. Take pictures of both the exteriors and interiors of vehicles to ensure you’ve documented all damage.
  • Write Down Details: Note the time, date, weather conditions, and any other observations that might be relevant. If another driver flees the scene, take down any identifying details of their vehicle (such as color, license plate number, etc.) that you remember.

Gather Witness Information

Witnesses can provide unbiased accounts of the accident, which can be pivotal in disputed fault cases:

  • Collect Contact Information: Obtain witnesses’ names, phone numbers, and addresses.
  • Ask for Statements: Get a brief account of the accident from witnesses. Witness statements are often most valuable immediately after collisions.

Report to Police

A police report is an essential document in car accident claims:

  • Inform the Police: Always call 911 to report the crash, especially when the accident involves significant damage, injuries, or disputed facts.
  • Cooperate Fully: Provide your account of the incident to the police and ensure their report accurately reflects your side of the story. However, be careful not to say anything suggesting you caused the crash. 

“Taking these steps diligently enhances your ability to present a well-documented case, which can be crucial when dealing with legal processes and insurance companies.”

Handling Communications with the Other Drivers and Insurers

Handling Communications with the Other Drivers and Insurers

After an accident, especially when fault is disputed, how you communicate with the other driver and insurance companies can influence your case’s outcome. The following guidelines can help you manage these communications safely and effectively.

What to Say and What Not to Say

Careful communication is critical to protecting your rights after a crash:

  • Be Cautious: Exchange only necessary information such as contact and insurance information. Avoid discussing the fault or details of the accident.
  • Do Not Admit Fault: Even casual remarks like “I’m sorry” can be misinterpreted as an admission of fault. In addition, don’t say you’re unharmed, as you might be injured without knowing it.

Contacting Your Insurance

Quickly informing your insurance company about the accident is crucial:

  • Report the Accident: Contact your insurer as soon as possible to report the accident. Provide a factual account of what happened without making assumptions about fault. 
  • Follow Their Guidance: Your insurance company may provide specific instructions on documenting damages and seeking medical attention.

Dealing with the Other Driver’s Insurance Company

Proceed cautiously if the other driver’s insurance company approaches you about the wreck:

  • Direct an Insurer to Your Attorney: It’s often best to refer any communication from the other party’s insurer to your personal injury lawyer. If you work with the claims adjuster directly, you run the risk of making statements that could harm your case.
  • Avoid Recorded Statements: Don’t give a recorded statement without speaking with an attorney. The insurance company could use these statements against you during settlement negotiations.

Legal Steps to Prove Fault When a Negligent Driver Denies It

You must thoroughly establish your case with solid evidence when an at-fault driver denies responsibility. The following steps can help you strengthen a claim:

Using Evidence from the Scene

The evidence collected at the accident scene plays a critical role in proving fault:

  • Detailed Documentation: Use the photos, videos, and notes taken at the scene to demonstrate the circumstances that led to the accident.
  • Accident Reconstruction: In some cases, your lawyer may employ an accident reconstruction expert to help clarify how the accident occurred and who is at fault based on the evidence.

Seeking Legal Help

Having an experienced lawyer can make a significant difference:

  • Professional Representation: An experienced car accident lawyer will know how to navigate the complexities of your case, negotiate with insurance companies, and, if necessary, represent you in court. 
  • Gathering Additional Evidence: Your lawyer can help gather further evidence, such as surveillance footage from nearby cameras, data from the vehicles’ electronic systems, or detailed witness testimonies that support your version of events.

Filing Legal Actions

You may take legal action if an insurance company stubbornly refuses to offer a fair settlement:

  • Filing a Lawsuit: Your experienced lawyer can file a lawsuit on your behalf. Even if the insurance company won’t settle, a jury may award you damages in court.
  • Mediation and Trial: Throughout the legal process, your lawyer will aim for the best possible outcome, whether through mediation or, if needed, at trial.

“Taking these legal measures not only helps to establish blame when it is contested, but it also increases your chances of collecting the money you are entitled to.”

Why Choose Manchin Ferretti for Your Car Accident Claim

Why Choose Manchin Ferretti for Your Car Accident Claim

Navigating a car accident claim always involves various steps and complex processes. Pursuing compensation where the other driver denies fault may also force you to investigate a case thoroughly. Securing the compensation you may be eligible for requires a comprehensive understanding of legal rights, meticulous documentation, and strategic communication.

Manchin Ferretti Injury Law has nearly four decades of experience in personal injury claims. We’ve managed to stay in business that long for a simple reason: We’re particularly adept at handling such challenging situations.

At Manchin Ferretti, we also recognize the physical, emotional, and financial toll that a car accident may take on individuals and families. Our strategy emphasizes winning cases and assisting people in rebuilding their lives with dignity and respect.

If you are involved in an accident where the fault is questionable, don’t navigate the legal waters alone. Contact us for a free accident review, and let our experienced team advocate for your rights while you focus on recovery.


Contact us For a Free Consultation


(304) 264-8505

Fill out the form below to get in touch!

100% privacy guarantee